J.W. Coon Elementary School, facing over $4.5 million in immediate repairs and costing more than $3 million annually to operate, will be closed by the Cumberland County Board of Education, displacing its students. Manchester Elementary will also close. The Board's 5-3 vote on these closures, reported by Fayobserver, WRAL, and ABC11 Raleigh-Durham, confirms a contentious decision.
The Cumberland County school board is closing underutilized and costly schools to improve efficiency. Yet, the decision involves complex timelines and consolidation plans that will disrupt communities for years, reflecting a strategic shift towards long-term financial efficiency over immediate stability.
While these immediate closures address pressing financial and capacity issues, the broader strategy points to a trend towards larger, more centralized school facilities across Cumberland County.
Why Manchester and J.W. Coon Are Closing
- Manchester Elementary operated at 72.48% capacity, with 295 students enrolled against a capacity of 407, according to Fayobserver.
- J.W. Coon Elementary School requires $4.5 million in immediate repairs, as reported by cityviewnc.
- The annual operational cost for J.W. Coon Elementary School exceeds $3 million, according to cityviewnc.
- The annual operational cost per student at J.W. Coon Elementary School is approximately $16,120, a figure highlighting severe inefficiencies, according to cityviewnc.
These figures reveal the significant challenges driving the closures. Manchester Elementary operated well below capacity, indicating inefficient resource allocation. J.W. Coon Elementary faced not only extensive immediate repair needs but also exceptionally high operational costs per student, making its continued operation financially unsustainable for taxpayers.
The Closure Process and Lingering Costs
The Cumberland County Board of Education initiated the closure process for Manchester and J.W. Coon elementary schools on April 2, according to cityviewnc. The proactive step of initiating the closure process demonstrates the board's determination to address the schools' long-term financial drain.
J.W. Coon Elementary School is projected to incur an additional $1.6 million in repair costs over the next seven years, according to cityviewnc. The Board of Education will absorb over $3 million annually in operational costs and defer $4.5 million in immediate repairs for J.W. Coon Elementary, with the deferral until at least 2026, based on cityviewnc's data. This approach prioritizes a large-scale, future-oriented solution over immediate, piecemeal fixes.
A Broader Consolidation Strategy
The Board approved a recommendation to consolidate J.W. Coon, Brentwood, and Sherwood Park elementaries into a single new elementary school designed for 900 students, as reported by Fayobserver. This consolidation is a strategic move towards creating larger, more efficient, and potentially newer school facilities. The consolidation represents a significant philosophical shift, moving towards centralized educational campuses and potentially eroding the traditional neighborhood school model across the county.
What Happens Next for Students and Families
J.W. Coon Elementary could close for the 2026-2027 school year, according to Fayobserver. This multi-year timeline allows the district to plan for student reassignments and new facility development. However, it also prolongs uncertainty and disruption for affected families and staff, highlighting the difficult trade-offs involved in the Board's long-term bet on efficiency and modernization.
